THE RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN “POLE DE PSYCHIATRIE INFANTO-JUVENILE DE RENNES” AND COPELFI:
A CASE OF IDENTIFICATION WITH THE AGGRESSOR?
A petition signed by the Group de Prefiguration de 2018, un temps de la Palestine a Rennes:
What is COPELFI?
COPELFI is the “Association pour les Conferences de Psychiatrie de l’Enfant et de l’Adolescent en Langue Française en Israël,” a joint association of French and Israeli child and adolescent psychiatrists. It was founded in 1989 by the French psychiatrists G. Gachnochi and M. Vincent, in partnership with the Israeli psychiatrist S. Tyano, with the goal of “promoting the exchange of clinical and therapeutic experience between child psychiatric professionals within France and Israel, as well as to stimulating creativity and acquainting our colleagues in Israel with new modes of thinking developed in France.” The leadership consisted of the President of COPELFI in France, Eric Ghozlan (Directeur du Pole Enfance à l ’association des Oeuvres de Sauvegarde de l’Enfance) and the President of COPELFI in Israel, Dolly Amoyelle. The Vice-President is G. Gachnochi and the General Secretary is Lydia Liberman-Goldenberg (Vice-Presidente de l’Association Francaise de Psychiatrie).
In 2011, celebrating the 20th year since the founding of COPELFI, G. Gachnochi stated in Israel Magazine:
“Our wish is to bring together annually French-speaking and Israeli practitioners, to establish a deep rapport. In contrast to all of the systematic distortions about Israel fostered in the European and international media, we aim to discover the actual Israeli realities, both in terms of the country overall and in terms of specific professional domains.”
Meanwhile, the Child and Adolescent Psychiatry Unit at the University of Rennes has been developing its concepts and practice-parameters in the area of trauma following acts of terrorism by making use of the model provided by the state of Israel, not only through cooperation with COPELFI but also through research in partnership with various Israeli universities. In 2018, this collaboration was manifested in several international symposia featuring the Pole pedopsychiatrie Rennes, Associations ALFEST, and COPELFI.
In May 2018, for example, there was a symposium in Paris entitled, “Trauma, Terror, Terrorism: Wave after Wave.” In October 2018, there was a symposium in Israel entitled, “The Attacks, their Trauma, and their Consequences.” There is currently a symposium planned at the University of Rennes1, France, for 14 December 2018, entitled: “Mobile Teams and Psychic Trauma: What is at stake? What are Best-Practices?”
We object to the December 2018 symposium because of its endorsement of the Israeli political narrative. What we observe indeed is that the state of Israel has fashioned its constitutional laws in order to colonize the Palestinian territories and to institute a policy of apartheid within its own borders over the past seventy years. Innumerable reports sponsored by the United Nations attest to the illegality of the occupation and its process of undermining the dignity and survival of the Palestinian people.
Surely the main focus of the international cooperation among mental health professionals is the psychological trauma suffered by victims of terrorism—especially its consequences for children and adolescents. Thus, to further research on trauma and its impact in the context of war, it is crucial to explore the elements of terrorism and oppression.
But to take the state of Israel as an example of victimhood is an act of complicity with its political program; its establishment of a colonial state and an apartheid society has inflicted untold damage. We argue, therefore, that psychiatric research and clinical partnerships on the ground—whether regarding the child, adolescent, or adult—must benefit the mental health system in Palestine.
Mental Suffering in Palestine
What are the consequences for the adults and children of Palestine, in terms of their bodies and minds, of the violence inflicted by military occupation, oppression, detention, torture, assassination, restriction of movement, displacement, demolition of homes, destruction of agriculture, and multiple other injuries? All of these questions must motivate our research and our support of Palestinian practitioners both in the arena of clinical practice and the construction of an accessible system of care.
We therefore demand, as a collective of citizens and professionals within the medical/social sector of Rennes (Groupe de Préfiguration de 2018—Un temps de la Palestine à Rennes):
- That the University of Rennes cease all professional and research collaboration with both COPELFI and other Israeli universities.
- That all mental health professionals in France refuse to participate in any symposium or conference in Israel, such the meeting in Tel Aviv of the International Association for Relational Psychoanalysis and Psychotherapy (IARPP) for June, 2019. In this demand, we support our 20,000 colleagues in Palestinian Union of Social Workers and Psychologists, who have asked for mental health clinicians internationally to refuse to attend the IARPP meeting in Tel Aviv and all similar conferences in Israel:
December 14, 2018 signed by:
Union Juive Francaise pour la Paix
L’Association France-Palestine Solidarite–Rennes
Nouveau Partie Anticapitaliste–Ille et Vilaine (35)
Jeunesse Communiste (35)
USA-Palestine Mental Health Network
TO SIGN THIS PETITION OR TO CONTACT THE ACTIVISTS AT RENNES, SEND AN EMAIL TO: 2018tempsdelapalestine@gmail.com
